Skip to content
    Lateral Law Report

    Courts · November 10, 2026

    Federal Court quashes refugee ruling over phantom quote

    Federal Court sets aside a refugee decision that relied on a quote from a Federal Court ruling that appears not to exist.

    The Federal Court has sent a refugee case back for a new hearing after finding that the tribunal relied on a quote, attributed to the Federal Court, that does not appear in any of its decisions.

    In Horvath v. Canada, decided November 3, the Refugee Protection Division had vacated a man's refugee status over a harassment matter in Hungary. In doing so, it cited a statement it attributed to the Federal Court: that Canadian courts have consistently treated criminal harassment as a serious non-political crime. Justice Angus Grant could not find that statement in any Federal Court ruling and said it was unclear how it got into the decision.

    The judge found the unattributed quote went to the central question of whether harassment counts as a serious crime under the Refugee Convention. Along with other errors, including how the tribunal dealt with the sentence that was actually imposed, it led him to set the decision aside.

    Counsel for the applicant told Canadian Lawyer he does not believe an AI tool was involved, and the Immigration and Refugee Board said its members are directed not to use AI tools in their adjudicative work. Whatever the cause, the case shows citation errors now coming from decision-makers as well as parties, and courts checking for them.

    Sources

    More headlines

    All headlines